Archive for the ‘Member Reviews’ Category

Garrett GTI 2500 Review by Eu_citizen

*Detectorstuff loves user submitted reviews!  Who better to give some advice and feedback than real life users who have plenty of hours behind the coil.  Read HERE for information on being a DetectorStuff review submitter!  Thanks Eu_citizen for another great review!

-Mark

Now when you break this thing out of it’s box… It looks impressive! Nice green colour, big display heavy and steadily built coils.

Everything looks good and so, now taking it into the field will tell if it’s good or not.

Read the rest of this entry »

Minelab Explorer 2 user review by Eu_Citizen

Eu_Citizen submitted this Minelab Explorer 2 review in the DetectorStuff User Reviews section of the forums. Feel free to write reviews of your own or comment on ones that are already here. Thanks for the submission Eu!

Ex2Well when you take it out of the box… It looks plain weird, not really impressive at first. After a while I did get used to the looks of it.

You’ll note it’s easy to put together. And will need adjusting to your length, otherwise it’s going to feel real heavy. (i.e. arm cup, lower rod need adjustments)

It’s not to bad when you’ve done that.

Ok when skimming through the manual you’ll note there aren’t many adjustments, just more or less weird names for them.

Just learn them. Oh and it is a bit noes heavy, if to heavy opt for another coil.

In the field:

Park:

Well I start out at the park and play around a bit and soon I noted.. “I need a smaller coil!”

Read the rest of this entry »

White's DFX Review by Eu_Citizen

One of DetectorStuff’s newest members, Eu-Citizen has hit the ground running with user submitted content! Here’s his review of the DFX…Thanks EU!

dfxSo where shall we begin with this beast?

When you take it out of the box, it doesn’t really look much. But as soon as you turn it on and want to adjust things.. Whoaa!


Lot’s of adjustments, you could ruin a whole weeks worth of detecting if you’d start out right away and try to adjust everything.

Read the rest of this entry »

White's Spectra V3 (Vision) Field Test part 1

White’s new flagship has proudly left port!…the Spectra V3!

Part 1 of however many it takes!

To say there are a LOT of features and options on White’s newest flagship, the Spectra V3, is an enormous understatement!    I’ve spent weeks deliberating on the best way to present a review of the Spectra…and I finally decided to break it into phases.  If I tried to put everything into one story, I think it would almost be overwhelming! (to me too…trying to write it!)  There will no doubt be some outstanding books and tutorials written on this machine.  I would strongly suggest buying one of those when they become available (Jeff Foster or Andy Sabisch?).

This first “phase” report is about the packaging, contents and overall new user impressions.  As the chapters continue, I will branch out into other aspects such as assembly, air-testing, interface and “real-world” usage.

So here we go!…

White’s Spectra V3 Review, part 1

Read the rest of this entry »

Fisher F5 Long Review (features breakdown)

I’ve had a lot of questions about the innovative F5 over the past few months.  This is a feature break down I did that was posted on Kellyco’s site.  Hopefully you’ll find it useful

Fisher F5 Field Test

Mark Ellington

Fisher F5 Face

Fisher F5 Face

I was given the wonderful opportunity to do some field testing with Fisher’s amazing new F5. The F5 is one of the most unique detectors I’ve put my hands on in a very long time! The perfect blend of cutting edge, software driven power meshed with the feel of good old fashioned knobs. I find it very interesting that the “oldest name in metal detecting” is utilizing the newest technology! The F5 is the result of Fisher’s self proclaimed “war on bad user interfaces”. The lead Engineer on the F5 was Jorge A. Saad.

Since Fisher Laboratories came under new management, the Company has not been resting on their laurels! First out of the gate came the incredible F75, followed by the mid-range F4. Next up was the affordable F2, then recently the incredibly deep F70. That leads us up to the innovative F5!

The F5 is situated in the familiar F2/F4 housing, but the electronics are entirely different. This platform was designed by Engineers Jorge Saad and Dave Johnson (with John Gardiner and Mark Krieger additionally lending their talents) to offer outstanding discrimination, depth and ID capabilities. You’ll find the F5 mounted on the familiar gold and black “S” rod which has proven its ergonomics and durability throughout the years.

*Click below to see the rest of the review*

Read the rest of this entry »

Official! "Hot off the press"

Fisher’s World Treasure News 2009! wtn-front-page

Fisher was kind enough to send it our way for distribution…if our servers can take the downloads!  By the way, overlook the mediocre writer in there named “mark” :)

*Update* WTN is now posted for download on Fisher Labs Website…get it HERE!

DetectorStuff Member Reviews

As most members know, I did a poll on the “old” Detector Stuff site asking if you would like for us to do “Member Reviews” of metal detectors and accessories.  You folks responded “YES!”

This desire by our members to have the ability to post reviews, tips, etc. was one of my motivating factors for moving to this new style site software….So, let’s do it!

Member Reviews!

Rules:

  • You MUST have owned and used the metal detector or accessory you’re writing about for at least 1 year.
  • Pointing out flaws is okay, but this is not a “bash-fest” (I’m sure y’all have seen what I’m talking about)
  • Write your review with the idea of “How can I describe this machine/accessory to someone who has never owned one”
  • Think of “helpful tips” that you’ve heard, learned or been taught by others.

You can submit your review/tutorial/tip list to me in two ways…

  1. Email it in any document format to:  detectorstuff@gmail.com
  2. Post it in the “Users Submitted Reviews and Articles Discussion” forum.

I will take your work and post it on the front page under “Member Reviews” with credit going to you…it will always be here!  Archived forever (or until I’m too broke to pay the site host!) for thousands to read and learn from.  Remember, my goal with DetectorStuff.com is to provide tons of cool information that is easy to find, helpful and good for the hobby.

One thing that may help you get started:  Pretend you are taking someone metal detecting with you who is using your same make/model metal detector.  Imagine it’s the first time they’ve ever used it and have a ton of questions for you since you’ve owned and used one for a long time…

Thanks!  I’m looking forward to posting your work and learning from all your experiences!

Mark

*DetectorStuff.com reserves the right to NOT post inflammatory reviews that help no one*

Sunray Headphones Review – Bill Ladd

Having now been treasure hunting now for over 25 years, I can’t imagine how many sets of headphones I have gone through. Back then, there were really no companies producing “detecting” headsets like there are today. So, many of us made do with whatever stereo type headphones that we could actually get to work on a metal detector. Of course headphones sun_ray_pro_hp-front_viewmade for listening to the stereo at home couldn’t handle the riggers of serious treasure hunting.

Nowadays, the metal detectorist has a wide array of headphone choices available with fancy names and price ranges that can go over $140.00….or close to the cost of a back-up detector! Thus the casual coinshooter may get along fine and enjoy a low priced pair, and this is great. But, someone like a relic or nugget hunter using headphones usually “thrown in” with a new detector purchase will be disappointed as these headsets rarely survive getting pushed and pulled in the field.

Read the rest of this entry »

"Above All Others" – NASA Tom

*Reprinted from NASA Toms site site link

To purchase NASA Tom’s outstanding metal detecting DVD, click HERE

ABOVE ALL OTHERS

Thomas J. Dankowski
Drafted…. mid-year 1998
Unedited version
Portions used by KellyCo

beach find with SD model Many professional treasure hunters have requested that I field test the Minelab ‘SD’ series detectors on the beach. Conclusive results are far greater than ever expected. It is difficult for me to genuinely convey this nearly inconceivable performance of these detectors to gain the respect and appreciation they deserve. Head-to-head comparison by request is, by far the most understood universal language among detectorists. Minelab Excalibur and Fisher ‘CZ’ series owners, this is your wake-up call.

The SD2100 and SD2200d provides a minimum of 30% greater depth and a minimum of 85% greater sensitivity to smaller objects in wet or dry sand (Atlantic ocean testing). Please understand the word “minimum”. Deliberately under varying conditions and different days, thousands of objects on the wet beach were detected with the SD detector and their pinpoint location marked. Over 85% of the objects were completely undetectable to the Excalibur and CZ with their settings adjusted for maximum stable performance utilizing comparable size coils, no handicaps given. And the SD has greater stability over the very stable Excalibur and CZ. The SD series detectors utilize a form of pulse induction for operation. Comparing to other P.I. detectors, the SD takes an even greater lead in performance. Furthermore, the SD has an affinity for gold, nickels and iron.

Operating procedures requires the absolute minimum; turn the unit on. That is it. There is no volume or sensitivity control and the dual ground balance controls are unaffected by wet or dry sand. Bring the coil to the ground and the SD will chirp once. Commence hunting. The factory preset tone control (headphone audio sound) and tune control (for electrical interference) never required adjusting.

Equipment and accessories are readily available for the SD series detectors, however, very little is needed. The optimum beach coil is the 11” monoloop. The 18” coil has too much feedback on wet sand creating instability, however, on dry sand the performance can be measured in feet, yards, and meters. With the 18” coil you cannot carry a shovel unless it is nonmetallic. The performance of the SD 2100 and SD2200d is nearly identical although the SD2200d has SURFACE discrimination capabilities and tone ID, nicely added features. Only a little bit of practice is required to learn these added features. Understandably, the price differential between the SD series detectors and other units is not comparable and furthermore, it may appear to be unjustifiable for a depth gain of only 30 plus %. Please understand this; a heavily hunted beach will appear to be undetected when operating a SD detector on the same beach. A noteworthy personal experience I had during field tests. I hunted a certain segment of wet beach for 90 minutes utilizing an Excalibur 1000. I recovered 4 items. With no room for error I retraced my exact footprints, this time using the SD unit. I recovered 37 more items (two of them gold). The quiet beach came to life in the SD’s headphones. Ironically, the SD2100 and SD2200d perform poorly with air tests, only average performance in a professional test garden, and will not function indoors. On the beach, performance is above all others – genuinely untouchable. The SD is not a toy. Also, keep in mind,,,, with virtually no discrimination– many, many iron items will be recovered.

beach find with SD model Out of my own curiosity, I also had the opportunity and the time to properly field test the SD2200d in an entirely different environment – relic hunting. Deliberately choosing severe soil conditions, I hunted an old home site in North Georgia where the ground consists of dark red clay. Almost all other detectors fail to operate with this type of soil because of its iron oxide content. The SD2200d with the 11” DD coil is the first metal detector that I have ever used that depth was completely unaffected by these paralyzing soil conditions. Tiny objects at extreme depths were commonplace, however, I did find a failure point of the SD2200d. All objects would ID as iron, even with the detector in Disc+ID mode. A silver dime and a brass bullet casing would “silence” the threshold audio (surface discriminate). No adjustments seemed to help the ID circuitry. Depth capabilities (performance) in the all-metal or Disc+ID mode were identical. The 11” monoloop consistently provided a depth increase of 4% over the 11” DD coil, no matter what the soil conditions consisted of. If the all-metal mode is the preferred choice for relic hunting, the SD series detectors once again is above all others.

Thomas J. Dankowski
Drafted…. mid-year 1998
Unedited version
Portions used by KellyCo

My personal opinion on the downside of the SD:

1. The SD is not rainproof.
2. Limited iron surface discrimination is insufficient and difficult to audibly understand.
3. The battery backpack is cumbersome.
4. The power cable interferes frequently.
5. The pie pan style coil sticks to wet sand like glue.
6. The detector stand is insufficient.
7. The 18” coil is extremely brittle and not waterproof.
8. Volume is insufficient on the SD2200d.

Powered by eShop v.5